Upper Merion is still pursuing its proposed sports, entertainment and housing development. Officials said so at the November 5 budget meeting, where Board Chair Tina Garzillo said the township had received state funding for engineering work, allowing it to move into the next phase of exploring the proposal. She cautioned that it was premature to say whether the project would happen. She did not specify the funding amount, program or engineering scope.

That update follows more than two years of consulting work, discussions with prospective sports tenants and developers, and efforts to assemble public financing.

In my July 30 report, I described the township's application for a $20 million state grant toward a proposed $197 million development. The application contemplated housing, shared parking and walkable connections alongside a multipurpose venue.

To understand how the proposal reached that point, I reviewed township meeting records and emails obtained through a Right-to-Know request. They show work involving supervisors and staff, sports organizations, a property owner, design and construction firms, county and state officials, the tourism board, outside lawyers and financial advisers.

The timeline below distinguishes the work the township authorized from the possibilities participants discussed, and identifies the questions the available records still leave unanswered.

How the proposal developed

February–July 2024 | A pitch became a township initiative

Richard Neumann contacted Board Chair Tina Garzillo and Township Manager Anthony Hamaday in February about a minor league baseball venue and related development. The consultant initiated that contact; later decisions to pursue and pay for studies belonged to the township. At the June 6 zoning workshop, Planning Director Jarrett Lash presented material on a possible minor league baseball and multipurpose facility, then introduced Neumann by Zoom. According to the workshop minutes preserved in a search-indexed copy of a former township packet, Neumann described his experience and spoke with supervisors about the concept. The July 18 meeting record lists those June 6 minutes among those approved by the board. Staff also drafted a general public statement describing exploratory work; I have not established whether it was delivered publicly. On July 18, supervisors approved Neumann's first consulting agreement on the consent agenda and separately approved an ordinance permitting spectator sports facilities in specified zoning districts.

The June workshop was a public discussion with the prospective consultant; the July votes authorized consulting work and changed zoning rules. Neither vote approved construction at a particular site. I have not yet obtained a working copy of the June 6 minutes or Lash's presentation from the current township archive.

September 2024–spring 2025 | Site and cost studies followed

On Sept. 12, supervisors approved $46,200 from General Fund reserves for an EwingCole venue study. The board separately approved Neumann for an economic development analysis related to multipurpose sports and entertainment facilities on Feb. 13, 2025. Emails later discuss multiple site studies, a Brandywine site, and construction estimates revised with input from LF Driscoll. Neumann's $25,000 economic and fiscal impact analysis was invoiced as delivered in March 2025; a township electronic-payment confirmation in April includes that fee.

The township paid Neumann for analysis and authorized EwingCole's study. I have not established what EwingCole or LF Driscoll was paid, and the full impact analysis was not in the email folders I received.

Spring–summer 2025 | Teams, land and advisers entered the picture

Emails discuss a potential move by the BlueClaws, contacts involving the Phillies, the possibility of professional soccer through United Soccer Leagues, and Brandywine Realty Trust property. Neumann recommended sports and development lawyers; the township's July 17 agenda listed the appointment of Nixon Peabody as special counsel. Attorneys Gregg Dorman and Michael Melzer subsequently appear in project-financing correspondence. State Rep. Tim Briggs participated in discussions about state funding and the county hotel tax.

The township and its consultant were testing prospective tenants, property and legal structures. The emails do not establish a team relocation agreement, a final site, a Phillies commitment or a Brandywine development agreement.

July 2025 | The housing and event assumptions grew more specific

In discussions about revising the economic-impact analysis to include soccer and concerts, township and consultant emails raised a model with 1,161 residential units, 10,000 square feet of office space and a seven-year construction period. One concert scenario used 28 shows a year, an average attendance of 2,500 and a $40 ticket price.

Housing and events were part of the projected economic case, not incidental decorations around a ballpark. These were assumptions under discussion, not approved apartments or a verified final report. The records do not place all 1,161 units on the 16.8-acre site later identified in the grant application.

July–August 2025 | A proposed soccer arrangement was put on paper

A July 30 letter described a stadium with at least 5,000 seats, a prospective women's professional team and potentially a men's team. It contemplated exclusive negotiations with USL and said the broader development could include multifamily housing, restaurants, retail, a hotel and entertainment uses. On Aug. 19, Hamaday circulated the township-signed six-page letter and asked colleagues to obtain USL's signature. The copy I received has a blank USL signature line.

Upper Merion signed its side of a specific proposed negotiating framework. I cannot establish that USL signed, that exclusivity took effect, or that any of the contemplated uses was approved. The stadium-requirements exhibit referenced in the letter is missing from this copy.

September 2025 | The township sought $20 million from the state

A copy printed Sept. 22 of its RACP application described a roughly $197 million mixed-use sports and entertainment development, including a roughly 7,500-seat multipurpose venue, housing, parking and walkability improvements. It referred to approximately 16.8 acres and listed 650 Park Avenue, but does not settle the final site. The proposed funding stack listed $20 million in requested RACP funds, $55 million in other state funding, $56 million private, $35 million township and $31 million county. It credited Neumann with an economic-impact analysis, EwingCole with preliminary design and LF Driscoll with a construction estimate. Lash requested support letters from county commerce director Stephen Forster, the tourism board and King of Prussia District. King of Prussia District President Eric Goldstein provided a district letter; Forster said he would see what he could do.

This was a detailed application and proposed financing plan. The listed sources were projections, not evidence that all parties had committed the amounts. The $20 million was requested for construction and site infrastructure, not to commission the earlier studies. I have not established whether county or tourism-board letters were ultimately provided.

August–October 2025 | Regional and school-district outreach expanded

Lash sought a meeting with Valley Forge Tourism & Convention Board CEO Mike Bowman and proposed including King of Prussia District President Eric Goldstein. Bowman suggested involving tourism-board colleague Jake Markezin and vice chair Tim Briggs. Neumann also pursued meetings with Upper Merion Area School District officials; an Oct. 6 invitation went to district email accounts for a project meeting.

Township staff were seeking to bring regional institutions into the discussion. The invitations alone do not establish attendance, endorsement or a school-district funding commitment.

Early 2026 | The design and consultant work continued

Planning Director Jarrett Lash circulated a conceptual Moore Park buildout spanning multiple parcels on and around First Avenue, with possible housing, retail, office and hotel uses; he cautioned that it had not been reviewed for full zoning compliance. EwingCole's Craig Schmitt said a traffic study would likely be needed, and Hamaday said the township had engaged transportation consultant Boles Smyth for a traffic study concerning a possible Turnpike slip ramp. He separately anticipated costs for First Avenue improvements. Supervisors approved a fee increase in February, considered revised Neumann terms in March, and the April board packet contained a 12-month agreement running through Dec. 31, 2026 at $12,500 a month, plus expenses and certain additional fees. An April 10 email said the final agreement had been approved and executed. The base monthly schedule totals $150,000 for 2026; it is not proof that every installment was paid.

The exploration continued into a third calendar year, with road and housing implications beyond the venue itself. Concept drawings, traffic work and revised consulting terms do not amount to land-development approval or a final site plan.

March–May 2026 | Residents and officials raised the question of what was being done

At the March 12 supervisors' meeting, resident Mike Napolitan questioned the consulting-agreement item. Hamaday said the monthly price had been approved in February, and Vice Chair Bill Jenaway explained his support for bringing in an expert to evaluate the opportunity. In May, Hamaday privately questioned whether to retain an owner's representative before the county's position was known, since the project might be delayed or might not happen.

The public record includes a resident asking about the consultant, and the internal record shows the manager still weighing whether to incur the next phase of costs. The minutes and these emails support scrutiny of the process, but not a claim that the supervisors had already approved construction.

April–May 2026 | Concert and county contacts broadened

Garzillo introduced Rising Sun Presents' Rich Kardon to Neumann about a possible large-scale township venture. Separately, Montgomery County official Erin Murphy Boyle arranged for county staff to hear an updated scope and financial briefing. Neumann's account of a May 27 meeting names township lawyers, Rep. Tim Briggs and tourism-board representatives. Garzillo later identified Brandywine CEO Jerry Sweeney as a potential master developer who joined the county discussion.

A promoter, property owner and regional officials were in the orbit of the proposal, but an introduction or a briefing is not a contract or an endorsement. Rising Sun's existing township concert work does not establish its retention for this development.

May 2026 | Lawyers and financial advisers modeled potential revenue

Nixon Peabody attorney Michael Melzer asked PFM Financial Advisors to test scenarios involving county hotel-tax revenue, township amusement tax, a projected $650,000 a year in incremental school-district amusement tax from the proposed stadium, team rent, naming rights and a possible RACP grant. Hamaday then said a separate $1 million township amusement-tax assumption had been used in the 2026 budget and should be removed from the project model.

Advisers were trying to see how debt might be supported. Those modeled revenues were not collected project income, approved tax allocations or signed tenant and sponsor commitments.

June 2026 | Garzillo sought a higher county hotel tax

In a June 10 letter to Montgomery County commissioners, the board chair asked for support for state enabling legislation that would permit a higher county hotel tax. She wrote that there could be “no Project without the bed tax increase” and acknowledged county commissioners would decide whether to levy and allocate any new revenue. Her letter described an approximately $200 million project budget excluding an estimated $40 million for land, a different scope or estimate from the earlier $197 million grant application. Neumann's June 15 email to state officials Amanda Warren and Rick Siger proposed raising the county rate from 4% to 8%, with three of the four added percentage points supporting the project and one for county purposes. On June 17, Siger replied that the state was not pressing a particular hotel-tax allocation and that the decision belonged to local partners.

This was a specific public-financing request, pursued through county and state channels. The letter and emails do not show a tax increase, county allocation or enacted legislation.

July 2026 | Financing and next-stage costs remained unsettled

Hamaday sent a township-signed J.P. Morgan engagement letter and asked for a fully executed copy; the copy I reviewed did not bear the bank's signature and did not obligate it to finance the project. Days later, he questioned who would pay for an additional $94,000 EwingCole schematic-design proposal and an owner's representative. He wrote that Brandywine's possible advance of design costs, to be reimbursed later, was on hold and that the work had not been budgeted for 2026. Neumann replied that the state, tourism board, King of Prussia District, Brandywine and the Phillies had indicated willingness to contribute.

The participants were still trying to assemble a financing and predevelopment plan. Those email statements do not establish signed pledges or payments by any of those organizations.

July–November 2026 | The $20 million request remained unawarded, while officials said the project continued

The township did not appear among recipients of the requested $20 million RACP grant in the state's initial July award announcement. When I asked Hamaday whether Upper Merion was still pursuing the proposal, he replied on September 29, “Mr. Luttrell, Yes.”

I also checked the state's RACP submissions-and-awards listing after its October 29 update. As of November 10, it still showed no award to Upper Merion for that request. The state says additional awards may be issued until the funding round officially closes.

At the November 5 budget meeting, Garzillo said the township had received state funding for engineering work, allowing it to move into the next phase of exploring the proposal. I recorded her remarks.

“We just got some funding from the state to be able to do some engineering,” she said. “Now that that's happened we can start going to that next phase of exploring. Right now it's premature to say yes or no it's going to happen.”

She did not specify the funding amount, program or engineering scope. Her remarks confirm that exploration continues, while leaving the project's eventual outcome unsettled. They do not identify how this funding relates to the larger financing plan or the unsuccessful $20 million RACP request.

What the record adds up to

Township electronic-payment confirmations in the RTK folders document $163,993.66 paid to Neumann & Associates from September 2024 through April 2026. That is a documented minimum for one consultant, not a current project-wide spending total. The email records I received extend through July 2026, but those payment confirmations cover only part of that period. The 2026 agreement called for $150,000 in monthly fees across the full year, plus expenses and specified additional fees; its schedule is not proof every installment was paid. The board's $46,200 EwingCole approval is a separate authorization; I have not added it to confirmed payments. I also cannot yet account for Nixon Peabody, LF Driscoll, other advisers or any later costs.

The record shows a sustained, funded exploration involving specific sites, prospective teams, outside firms and multiple levels of government. It also shows public board discussions and approvals. What it does not establish is a final tenant, a USL-countersigned agreement, secured county or school-district funding, an approved development plan or a complete accounting of the money spent.

The November 5 meeting provides a more recent public confirmation that the effort continues. It also adds another question: How much state funding has the township received, through which program, and what engineering work will it pay for?

Other questions remain. Which site and housing program is now being pursued? Which team or developer, if any, has committed? What public money has been spent across all firms, and what further spending is authorized? Has the proposed hotel-tax arrangement advanced, and what financing alternatives are being considered?

The available records trace how the proposal developed. They do not yet provide a complete account of its current cost, financing or next steps.

Have questions? You can e-mail me at [email protected], I answer all my emails.

Enjoying the Spotlight? Don't stop here.

The best local stories come from the community. Have something that deserves the Spotlight? Email us at [email protected]

Thank you for reading,

Corey