The Upper Merion Area School Board received an extensive presentation Monday evening, November 16, outlining changes to the district's instructional programs, student assessments, curriculum development and long-term planning.

During the virtual Curriculum/Technology/Student Services Committee meeting, Assistant Superintendent Dr. Brian Riley described several initiatives intended to improve how the district evaluates student performance and identifies areas needing additional support.

The presentation also prompted concerns from longtime School Board Director Gary Ledebur about academic proficiency levels that he said have shown limited improvement over more than a decade.

BOARD DIRECTOR QUESTIONS LONG-STANDING ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE

Ledebur, who said he is beginning his 12th year on the board, expressed concern about the percentage of district students who have not achieved proficiency in English language arts and mathematics.

"For 12 years, we have struggled with 30% of our kids unable to achieve a proficiency in ELA and math," Ledebur said.

He specifically referenced third-grade English language arts scores, saying they have improved only marginally during his tenure.

Ledebur encouraged the district's newly assembled instructional leadership team to prioritize students who have historically struggled academically, including economically disadvantaged students, English language learners and other student groups experiencing achievement gaps.

His remarks were supportive of the administration's proposed direction but emphasized the importance of producing measurable results.

The percentages cited by Ledebur were not accompanied by a detailed historical performance analysis during the meeting.

DISTRICT CHANGES STUDENT ASSESSMENT REQUIREMENTS

Riley explained that the district has modified its assessment calendar to create more consistent and comparable student performance data.

Previously, some English language arts and mathematics benchmark assessments were optional during certain periods of the school year.

Under the revised approach, both subjects will have required assessments in the fall, winter and spring.

The district has also shortened the window for administering certain assessments from approximately three months to three weeks.

Riley explained that the previous arrangement made comparisons difficult because students tested at different points within a three-month window could have received substantially different amounts of instruction.

The new schedule is intended to provide more reliable comparisons across classrooms, buildings and grade levels.

The district is also expanding its use of LinkIt, a student data platform purchased two years ago, to analyze multiple measures of student performance and identify areas requiring additional instructional support.

Riley acknowledged that the district's curriculum audit identified weaknesses in its assessment system, which the administration is now working to address.

STATE ASSESSMENT RESULTS REMAIN UNAVAILABLE TO THE PUBLIC

Another complication involves the delayed release of statewide student assessment results.

Riley said that while Pennsylvania school districts have received access to certain assessment information for internal purposes, the results have not yet been publicly released.

He explained that the state has been reviewing how student performance levels are determined, including whether existing proficiency thresholds remain appropriate.

According to Riley, the district has been told the data could become publicly available in early 2027.

In the meantime, the administration intends to rely on additional measures, including benchmark assessments, diagnostic testing and classroom-based assessments, to evaluate student progress.

ELEMENTARY SCHOOL SCHEDULES COULD CHANGE NEXT YEAR

The district is also developing a new elementary school schedule for the 2027-28 school year.

Riley explained that this year's schedule was designed in part to accommodate the implementation of new HMH reading programs.

However, the administration wants to develop a more permanent schedule that addresses additional instructional needs.

An elementary scheduling committee has been established with representation from district administrators, principals and teachers across all elementary schools.

The committee has begun working with scheduling consultant Dr. Michael Reddick.

Riley said another meeting is planned for December, after which the district hopes to share a preliminary version of the proposed schedule.

No specific schedule changes were announced Monday.

NEW HIGH SCHOOL COURSES PROPOSED

District administrators also discussed several courses expected to be included in the high school's 2027-28 Program of Studies.

Among the proposals are:

  • Algebra 2 Concepts, an additional mathematics course within the district's special education programming.

  • Guitar 2, a half-credit elective for students who have completed Guitar 1 and want to continue developing their musical skills.

  • Concepts of World History, an existing course returning as part of the district's established rotation.

The administration expects to present the updated Program of Studies for board approval in December.

DISTRICT REORGANIZES INSTRUCTIONAL LEADERSHIP

Monday's meeting also introduced three administrators serving in the district's reorganized Office of Education.

The office brings curriculum, technology and student services under a more coordinated administrative structure.

The newly introduced leadership team includes:

  • Maura Murphy, Director of Teaching and Learning

  • Julie Oberle, Supervisor of Humanities

  • Jennifer Thompson, Supervisor of STEM

Riley explained that the reorganization replaced two curriculum director positions with supervisory positions reporting to a single Director of Teaching and Learning.

The district hopes the new structure will improve collaboration across academic departments and student support services.

COMMUNITY INVITED TO HELP SHAPE NEXT THREE-YEAR PLAN

The district has begun preparing its next comprehensive plan, which will guide priorities beginning with the 2027-28 school year.

The plan must be submitted to the Pennsylvania Department of Education by March 31, 2027.

As part of that process, UMASD has launched a community survey seeking feedback from parents, residents, employees and other stakeholders.

The survey will remain open through November 24.

Participants can also indicate whether they are interested in serving on the district's comprehensive planning steering committee.

Riley said 108 responses had been received by the time of Monday's presentation.

The district expects to notify selected steering committee participants by December 1, with an initial meeting tentatively scheduled for December 10.

A draft of the comprehensive plan is expected to be available for public review in February before the board considers its approval.

During the discussion, Ledebur cautioned that producing comprehensive plans does not necessarily result in better student outcomes.

Drawing on his experience as an administrator in the School District of Philadelphia, he encouraged district officials to focus on implementing improvements rather than spending excessive time developing plans.

Riley acknowledged the importance of monitoring implementation and evaluating whether the district's strategies are producing results.

WHAT COMES NEXT?

Monday's presentation outlined numerous changes, many of which are still being developed or implemented.

Several developments warrant continued attention:

  • Whether the district's new assessment practices produce measurable improvements in student achievement.

  • How historical proficiency data compare with the concerns raised by Ledebur.

  • What changes are proposed for elementary school schedules.

  • Whether the high school course additions receive board approval in December.

  • How the district incorporates public feedback into its next comprehensive plan.

For residents interested in participating in the planning process, the most immediate opportunity is the district's community survey, which closes November 24.

The meeting was informational, and the curriculum and planning initiatives discussed were not presented for a substantive board vote Monday evening.

Enjoying the Spotlight? Don't stop here.

The best local stories come from the community. Have something that deserves the Spotlight? Email us at [email protected]

Thank you for reading,

Corey