The Upper Merion Area School Board voted unanimously Monday evening, November 9, to withdraw six pending property tax-assessment appeals and transfer $7.725 million from the district's General Fund to its Capital Reserve Fund.

Although the two actions appeared as separate agenda items, Business Administrator Michael Keeley explained that both resulted from the conclusion of a court case involving King of Prussia Associates.

The board approved both measures by a 9-0 vote during its virtual Operations/Facilities Committee meeting.

SIX PROPERTY TAX APPEALS WITHDRAWN

The district had initiated six assessment appeals involving several commercial properties, including the King of Prussia Mall and properties along Allendale Road and DeKalb Pike.

Keeley explained that the Pennsylvania Supreme Court recently denied the district's petition for allowance of appeal in the King of Prussia Associates case, bringing the appeals process to an end.

According to Keeley, the Montgomery County Court of Common Pleas had placed the district's other assessment appeals on hold while the King of Prussia Associates litigation proceeded.

With that litigation concluded, Keeley said those appeals could no longer move forward.

The board subsequently authorized the withdrawal of all six appeals.

The affected properties include:

  • 140 Allendale Road

  • 150 Allendale Road (two parcels)

  • 201 Allendale Road

  • 251 W. DeKalb Pike

  • King of Prussia Mall (four parcels)

The withdrawals come amid ongoing concerns about the financial effects of property tax-assessment appeals on the district.

As previously reported by Upper Merion Area Spotlight, district officials have discussed significant reductions in assessed property values resulting from appeals filed by property owners.

These newly withdrawn cases are different because the district itself initiated the appeals.

The underlying court decisions, and their potential implications for future district-initiated assessment appeals, warrant additional examination.

$7.725 MILLION TRANSFER EXPLAINED

Keeley also explained why the administration recommended transferring $7,725,000 from the General Fund to the Capital Reserve Fund.

During the King of Prussia Associates litigation, the district was required to place 25% of the property taxes paid under protest by King of Prussia Associates into an escrow account.

According to Keeley, that account totaled $7,721,727 as of June 30, 2026.

Although the district had received the money, accounting requirements prevented it from recognizing those funds as revenue while the litigation remained unresolved.

Instead, the amount was recorded as a deferred revenue liability.

With the Pennsylvania Supreme Court declining to hear the appeal before the district's 2025-26 financial statements were issued, Keeley explained that the funds must now be recognized as revenue for that fiscal year.

The administration recommended transferring $7.725 million into the Capital Reserve Fund to support the district's long-term capital project plan.

The board approved the transfer unanimously.

There is an important distinction concerning this money.

Once transferred to the Capital Reserve Fund, it cannot be returned to the General Fund.

The money is restricted to specific purposes, including capital improvements, infrastructure, deferred maintenance, debt service and school buses.

The administration did not identify specific projects that would receive the transferred funds during Monday's meeting.

NEW AGREEMENT WITH LOCAL POLICE APPROVED

The board also unanimously approved a Memorandum of Understanding between the district and three local police departments:

  • Upper Merion Police Department

  • Bridgeport Police Department

  • West Conshohocken Police Department

The 14-page agreement establishes procedures for reporting incidents involving students, including offenses that require immediate notification to law enforcement and others for which school administrators have discretion.

It also addresses student interviews, parental notification, students with disabilities, police investigations and the exchange of information between schools and law enforcement.

Such agreements are required under Pennsylvania's Safe Schools Act and must be reviewed and re-executed every two years.

The board approved the agreement without substantive public discussion of its provisions.

Whether the new document contains significant changes from the district's previous agreement remains to be determined.

TENNIS COURT PROJECT STILL AWAITING PERMIT

During board comments, Director Maggie Philips requested an update on the district's tennis court construction project.

Director of Operations Robert Malkowski said the district still had not received the necessary permit from Upper Merion Township.

According to Malkowski, the township engineer had requested additional calculations or a review of calculations associated with the project.

He said he had not received a subsequent response and planned to follow up with the township engineer.

Board members expressed frustration with the continuing delay.

The district previously approved a construction contract with Miller Sports Construction totaling $2,569,450, along with a contingency allowance of up to $675,000 for rock removal and unsuitable soils.

It remains unclear when construction will proceed.

QUESTIONS WORTH FOLLOWING

Monday's meeting provided explanations for two significant financial decisions, but several questions remain.

The most consequential involve the King of Prussia Associates litigation.

What did the lower courts determine, and what implications might those decisions have for the district's ability to challenge commercial property assessments in the future?

How much additional tax revenue had the district hoped to generate through the six appeals it has now withdrawn?

And which capital projects will ultimately benefit from the $7.725 million transfer?

I'll continue examining the underlying records and following up on these matters as additional information becomes available.

Enjoying the Spotlight? Don't stop here.

The best local stories come from the community. Have something that deserves the Spotlight? Email us at [email protected]

Thank you for reading,

Corey