In June 2021, Upper Merion Supervisor Greg Waks shared some encouraging financial news on Facebook.
The township's Police Pension Fund, he announced, was overfunded by nearly $3.5 million.
Waks credited strong investment performance, the Pension Advisory Board and an earlier decision to lower the assumed investment return, which he explained had required the township to contribute more money.
He described Upper Merion's police pension as one of the best-funded in Pennsylvania.

Fast-forward four years.
According to Upper Merion Township's 2025 audited financial report, the Police Pension Fund now has a $17.6 million shortfall.
After examining the Police Department's proposed 2027 budget, I decided to dig a little deeper into its pension expenses.
Here's what I found.
FROM A SURPLUS TO A SHORTFALL
At the end of 2021, the Police Pension Fund was 112.5% funded, with approximately $86.9 million in assets and $77.2 million in estimated pension obligations.
By the end of 2025, the fund had approximately $86.4 million in assets against $104 million in obligations.
That left it just 83.1% funded.

Upper Merion's Police Pension Fund had approximately $86.9 million in assets and $77.2 million in estimated liabilities at the end of 2021. By the end of 2025, assets stood at $86.4 million while liabilities had grown to $104 million. Source: Upper Merion Township audited financial reports.
So, what happened?
Part of the explanation is a significant investment loss in 2022, when the fund lost approximately $17.1 million.
Although investments subsequently recovered, the estimated cost of future pension benefits continued growing.
Between 2021 and 2025, those obligations increased by approximately $26.8 million.
In other words, by the end of 2025, the pension fund had roughly the same amount of money it held four years earlier, but substantially more in retirement obligations.
WHAT THE PENSION CONSULTANT RECOMMENDED
Here's another finding worth examining.
At the June 12, 2024 Pension Advisory Board meeting, township pension consultant Jim Kennedy of Thomas Anderson & Associates discussed the fund's financial condition.
According to the meeting minutes, Kennedy explained that the township was using a method that spreads investment gains and losses over time when calculating its annual pension funding requirement.
He estimated that the township's minimum funding obligation under that approach was approximately $2.4 million, compared with approximately $3.9 million using current market values.
Kennedy strongly recommended that the township contribute more than the smoothed minimum to help protect the fund against future losses.
The minutes also record a recommendation to lower the assumed investment return to 7%.
Supervisor Greg Waks and Township Manager Tony Hamaday were among those listed as attending the meeting.

Minutes from the June 12, 2024 Pension Advisory Board meeting document recommendations from township pension consultant Jim Kennedy concerning pension contributions and the assumed investment return.
WHY THE ASSUMED INVESTMENT RETURN MATTERS
Pension calculations depend partly on how much officials expect the fund's investments to earn over time.
Generally, assuming higher future returns reduces the amount calculated as necessary today to cover future benefits. Lower assumed returns increase that calculated obligation.
Upper Merion's 2025 audit uses a 7.25% assumed investment return.
The report also cautions that the fund's anticipated long-term returns may be lower and recommends that township officials examine the costs of reducing that assumption.
The audit illustrates the potential impact:
At 7.25%, the reported pension shortfall is $17.6 million.
At 6.25%, the calculated shortfall increases to $30.9 million.
The 6.25% figure is an illustrative calculation, not a specific recommendation to adopt that rate.
And a larger calculated shortfall would not mean taxpayers must immediately pay the entire difference.
But these assumptions matter because they can affect future pension funding requirements.
WHAT DOES THIS MEAN FOR TAXPAYERS?
The township's budgeted share of police pension contributions has already increased substantially.
In 2024, Upper Merion budgeted approximately $1.57 million for its contribution.
The proposed 2027 budget includes approximately $3.47 million.
That's an increase of approximately 121% in three years.
Pension contributions are just one part of the township's budget, but they represent a continuing obligation that must be considered alongside other municipal expenses.
QUESTIONS WORTH ASKING
The financial reports explain much of what happened to the pension fund. But the public records leave several important questions unanswered.
Did the township follow the pension consultant's June 2024 recommendation to contribute more than the minimum required amount?
Did officials evaluate his recommendation to lower the assumed investment return to 7%?
What is the township's plan to address the Police Pension Fund's shortfall?
How much does the township expect police pension contributions to cost taxpayers over the next several years?
There's also a transparency issue worth noting.
The township's Agenda Center includes minutes for all five listed Pension Advisory Board meetings in 2024.
For 2025, only two meetings are listed, with minutes available for one. In 2026, five agendas are listed, but no corresponding minutes are currently displayed.
That makes it difficult for residents to follow recent discussions about a fund with more than $100 million in estimated retirement obligations.
THE BOTTOM LINE
Upper Merion's Police Pension Fund went from a surplus in 2021 to a reported $17.6 million shortfall in 2025.
The township's own records document the investment losses, increasing retirement obligations and recommendations from its pension consultant.
What remains unclear is how officials responded to those recommendations and what the financial consequences may be for future budgets.
With the proposed 2027 township budget under consideration, these are questions residents may want to ask.
WHO OVERSEES THE PENSION FUND?
The township maintains a Pension Advisory Board/Health and Welfare Board of Trustees, which includes township officials, employee representatives and appointed residents.
The township's website identifies Joan Jenaway as chairperson and Supervisor Greg Waks as the Board of Supervisors liaison.
Residents can review the full membership and the board's responsibilities on the township's official website
SOURCES
Upper Merion Township 2025 Annual Comprehensive Financial Report, pension financial position and actuarial assumptions, printed pages 60–63.
2025 Audit, Historical Pension Funding Schedule, printed page 78.
Upper Merion Township Pension Advisory Board, June 12, 2024 meeting minutes, page 1.
Upper Merion Township adopted 2024 budget and proposed 2027 budget.
Supervisor Greg Waks, public Facebook post dated June 18, 2021.
Enjoying the Spotlight? Don't stop here.
The best local stories come from the community. Have something that deserves the Spotlight? Email us at [email protected]
Thank you for reading,
Corey
